Fam. From hospitals and clinics to data warehousing companies, overcoming implicit biases with the help of up-to-date data can improve patient care and team member equity. Implicit bias informs our decision-making, emotional responses, and assumptions in our careers and personal lives. of completion that can be used to directly apply for CE credits. Implicit bias has been demonstrated as pervasive among health care professionals and having harmful effects on patient health. %%EOF WebImplicit Bias Education and Training in Healthcare - Elite Learning Continuing Education Healthcare Nursing Nursing Alabama Alaska Arizona Arkansas California Colorado Whether within a health system, clinic, or a data and analytics company, addressing implicit biases with team members (from providers and clinicians to data analysts) can improve performance and equity because it allows team members to better understand personal roadblocks to developmentinherent prejudices. Region V PHTC, HRSA, HHS or the U.S. Government. All employees in a healthcare setting including all medical providers and staff. Studies show people can be consciously committed to egalitarianism, and deliberately work to behave without prejudice, yet still possess hidden negative prejudices or stereotypes. Psychol. Participants are eligible for CME through the AAFP Credit System starting summer 2020. The George Washington University School of Medicine and Health Sciences is accredited by the Accreditation Council for Pharmacy Education as a provider of continuing pharmacy education. The effect of implicit bias in both a historical and present day By not making a selection you will be agreeing to the use of our cookies. They may see an immigrant with poor English skills and assume that the patient wouldnt be able to comprehend a complex medical situation. This is a 3-module course designed to help users learn what bias is, how to recognize it, and how to minimize its impact. Unauthorized use of these marks is strictly prohibited. Jerry Kang, vice chancellor for equity, diversity and inclusion, and professor of law at UCLA Law, states: Automatically, we categorize individuals by age, gender, race and role. Variation in orthopedic surgeons perceptions of the indications for and outcomes of knee replacement. The following groups qualify for a $50 per person discount: If you fall within one of these categories, send an email to OHEI-training@med.umich.edu and request a promo code for the category you qualify for. Identify and work to transform formal and informal norms that ignore and/or support racism. 5. Washington, DC: AAMC. Weight bias among health professionals specializing in obesity. Blacks are much more likely than whites to die of COVID-19. Science. March of Dimes leads the fight for the health of all moms and babies. Using techniques to de-bias patient care, which include training, intergroup contact, perspective-taking, emotional expression, and counter-stereotypical exemplars. For other programs not listed, we provide a certificate All Rights Reserved. Organizations looking to maximize Careers. Disclaimer. Addressing bias remains a fundamental professional responsibility of those accountable for the health and wellness of our populations. They come from countries like Ghana to work in places like Kansas. Allina Health and Health Catalyst used data to discover that implicit biases existed within their companies. The leadership team also decided to implement the trainings in other areas of the organization based on data-backed disparities. Nonpartisan forever. 3. States are aiming to reduce the gaps between White and minority populations in health outcomes, especially for women after giving birth. The This is an archive of the monthly CFAS Rep Bulletin newsletter for CFAS reps. Evidence of race evaluations from ages 6 and 10 and adulthood. endstream endobj 133 0 obj <. 2003;11(9):1033-9. How a physician communicates, his or her body language and verbal cues can be an expression of subconscious bias. But the disparities she saw during COVID-19 disturbed her, with far greater disease and death in ZIP codes with the highest concentrations of Black people and immigrants. A year after the Maryland General Assembly passed Pea-Melnyks perinatal bill, she introduced the measure that now mandates implicit bias training as a requirement for licensing in the state. When the IAT was administered at an obesity conference, participants implicitly associated obese people with negative cultural stereotypes, such as bad, stupid, lazy and worthless.8,9 Implicit gender bias among physicians also may unknowingly sway treatment decisions. Systemic racism in U.S. health care. WebElizabeth Gadioli will be presenting "Implicit Bias Training for the Healthcare Professional", a license required seminar addressing how unconscious thoughts and attitudes can impact care in the medical and dental professions. by the American Nurses Credentialing Centers Commission on Accreditation. They negatively impacted patient access to important resources like hospice care. Implement work policies and clinical procedures that protect clinicians from high cognitive load and promote positive emotions. Establish monitoring systems in which processes and outcomes of care can be compared by patient race. Promote racial diversity at all levels of the organizational hierarchy and support positive intergroup contact. These biases permeate the health care system and affect patients via patient-clinician communication, clinical decision making, and institutionalized practices. Watch the video , MHA Headquarters2112 University Park Dr.Okemos, MI 48864Phone: (517) 323-3443Fax: (517) 323-0946, MHA Capitol Advocacy CenterCapital Tower110 W. Michigan Ave.Suite 1200Lansing, MI 48933Phone: (517) 703-8601Fax: (517) 703-0628. She defines health inequalities as health differences that are not only unnecessary and avoidable but, in addition, are considered unfair and unjust. She also states that equity in health implies that, ideally, everyone should have a fair opportunity to attain their full health potential and, more pragmatically, that no one should be disadvantaged from achieving this potential, if it can be avoided.3,4. The Safari, Firefox, or Chrome browsers are recommended for best results. The PubMed wordmark and PubMed logo are registered trademarks of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). Am. Some examples of how implicit bias plays out in health care include: Implicit bias is not isolated to adult care. 1. Former AAMC Chief Diversity Officer Marc A. Nivet, Ed.D., interviews Howard Ross, founder and former chief learning officer of Cook Ross, Inc., and author of Reinventing Diversity: Transforming Organizational Community to Strengthen People, Purpose and Performance. Dr. Quinn Capers, a cardiologist and an associate dean at the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center, who has also done training in implicit bias at dozens of academic medical centers, has seen medical providers in his training courses looking at their phones and checking their watches. The impact of racism on clinician cognition, behavior, and clinical decision making. Register. Soc Sci Med. Hu X, Walker MS, Stepanski E, Kaplan CM, Martin MY, Vidal GA, Schwartzberg LS, Graetz I. JAMA Netw Open. 2017 Feb;100(2):372-376. doi: 10.1016/j.pec.2016.09.005. COURSE OBJECTIVES Defining implicit bias. doi: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2022.25485. Seek out cultural competence training; Ask for training on implicit biases, cultural competence, diversity, and health equity; Overcoming biases is Patient Educ Couns. | The next step is to create a training program that will have the highest likelihood of success, incorporating four best practices: Allina Health offered three implicit bias training sessions in 2019 and plans to offer additional trainings in 2020. shifting, becoming more diverse. Coming in 2020, the company also plans to roll out a second round of implicit bias training to focus on additional tools and actions to support an inclusive culture. The presenters for this course have declared no conflicts of interest. The goal of the project is to make this technique available for education (including self-education) and awareness. Indeed, Unequal Treatment found that even with the same insurance and socioeconomic status, and when comorbidities, stage of presentation and other confounders are controlled for, minorities often receive a lower quality of health care than do their white counterparts. Schwartz MB, et al. About the Course. Explicit bias, on the other hand, implies that there is awareness that an evaluation is taking place. On the eve of the 15th anniversary of two seminal reports from the Institute of Medicine (IOM) Crossing the Quality Chasm1 and Unequal Treatment2 we find that racial and socioeconomic inequity persists in health care. The course starts with core definitions of bias in both every day and professional life. A decade of studying implicit racial/ethnic bias in healthcare providers using the implicit association test. Tversky A, Kahneman D. Judgment under uncertainty: Heuristics and biases. Introduction. Du Bois Review. Implicit bias can shape the way healthcare professionals interact with patients. Knowing the National Standards for Culturally and Linguistically Appropriate Services in Health and Health Care (the, Performing teach back (e.g., the National Patient Safety Foundations Ask Me 3, Assiduously practicing evidenced-based medicine.. 1996;23(4):730-8. We offer a conceptual model demonstrating that provider-level implicit bias interventions should be accompanied by interventions that systemically change structures inside and outside the health care system if the country is to succeed in influencing biases and reducing health inequities. Subscribe to the MHA Monday Report weekly newsletter or our podcast, the MiCare Champion Cast, to keep informed about the latest healthcare news and events in Michigan. Recognize ones potential for implicit bias and apply strategies, such as the CARES FrameworkTM and practice cultural humility, to effectively mitigate their own implicit biases. Social explanations moderate whether ostensible negative associations are prejudice-based or empathy-based. Studies on social and economic determinants of population health, No. Green AR, et al. Feagin J, Benenefield Z. 4. Recognizing situations that magnify stereotyping and bias. Racial Differences in Patient-Reported Symptoms and Adherence to Adjuvant Endocrine Therapy Among Women With Early-Stage, Hormone Receptor-Positive Breast Cancer. There was actually a bit of backlash to the directive from Gov. Privacy Policy This workshop He works closely with public and private providers to more formally integrate social correlates of health in standards of patient care., The presenters for this course have declared no conflicts of interest, Senior Director of Health Equity, Mathematica. https://diversity.nih.gov/sociocultural-factors/implicit-bias-training-course We cannot change what does not exist, especially when there is no voice to object. 2000;343(14):1016-22. Once people understand the fundamentals behind implicit biasesand that everyone has themteam members were prepared for a deeper dive into their biases. Implicit biasoccurs when people act on the basis of preconceived prejudices and stereotypes without intending to do so. Epub 2022 Feb 7. What professions need to comply with this new rule regarding Implicit Bias Training? Rojas JC, Fahrenbach J, Makhni S, Cook SC, Williams JS, Umscheid CA, Chin MH. Keywords: Journal of General Internal Medicine. We support research, lead programs, and provide education and advocacy so that every family can have the best possible start. Framework for Integrating Equity Into Machine Learning Models: A Case Study. Misrepresenting racethe role of medical schools in propagating physician bias. Of all forms of inequity, injustice in health care is the most shocking and inhuman., Martin Luther King, Jr., National Convention of the Medical Committeefor Human Rights, Chicago, 1966. The whole point of implicit bias training is to create better health outcomes for Black patients and others who might be the target of discrimination, but the opposite seems more likely. Health care providers hold negative explicit and implicit biases against marginalized groups of people such as racial and ethnic minoritized populations. 11. During this webinar, participants will receive an overview of unconscious bias, reflect upon how their own biases manifest, and receive guidance on how to recognize and mitigate their biases when conducting, reviewing, and scoring virtual or in-person interviews. 2020 saw a lot of talk about implicit bias training in healthcare- and very little action. Read how Minneapolis-based Allina Health has been working toward health care equality after finding a disparity with its Black patients. At a well-known academic medical center, a child presented with difficulty breathing that baffled the care team. Q-and-A with Howard Ross About the Unconscious Bias Learning Lab, SGEA Call for General Positions, Steering Committee Chair, CPD Section Chair, MESRE Section Chair, Member at-Large, Southern Group on Educational Affairs. We help you measure, assess and improve your performance. Uninsurance rates were high among women of childbearing age, a new study found. WebImplicit bias in healthcare has been described as a fragmented area of research and there is an evolving area of medical and educational approaches to train physicians and nurses on how to recognize, reflect and change implicit bias to avoid harm to patients. 15. The https:// ensures that you are connecting to the In Crossing the Quality Chasm, the IOM stressed the importance of equity in care as one of the six pillars of quality health care, along with efficiency, effectiveness, safety, timeliness and patient-centeredness. With Implicit Bias Hurting Patients, Some States Train Doctors, researcher on implicit bias in health care, Hurdles Limit Uptake for FCC's Affordable Connectivity Program, Potential Biodiversity Refuges in Chilean Patagonia, Why Civil Courts Should Improve Defendant Notification, PA Makes Progress Toward Public Pension Sustainability. )17 that help lower racial bias include: In order to ensure best outcomes and zero harm for all patients, implicit bias and racial discrimination in health and health care should be better understood, assessed and corrected. Implicit (subconscious) bias refers to the attitudes or stereotypes that affect our understanding, actions and decisions in an unconscious manner.13 These biases, which encompass both favorable and unfavorable assessments, are activated involuntarily and without an individuals awareness or intentional control.14, In 1995, Anthony Greenwald and M.R. This View them by specific areas by clicking here. Download the presentation highlighting the key main points. At the end of this training, participants will be able to: Define the concepts of unconscious and implicit bias Differentiate types of implicit biases Discuss creating an inclusive environment Discuss counterproductive implicit bias and microaggression actions Explain strategies to lead employees through the implementation of new anti-bias Please email us an email at, If you have questions about this program or group training sessions, send us an email WebUnlike the human trafficking training requirement, this is not a one time training. The team of physicians were agonizing over a light box, reviewing the patients X-rays, puzzled because they couldnt determine a diagnosis. Baron AS, Banaji MR. Once an individual is mapped into that category, specific meanings associated with that category are immediately activated and influence our interaction with that individual.. 16. The impact of implicit bias on healthcare disparities goes beyond physician decision making on the wards, in the bronchoscopy suite, or the intensive care unit. Journal of General Internal Medicine. Understanding and respecting the magnitude of unconscious bias. Someone who made you or a loved one feel seen, heard or respected as a patient? 2021 Apr 21;36(3):298-311. doi: 10.1093/heapol/czaa190. Its not that those doctors were racists or bad people, Cooper said. Amutah C, Greenidge K, Mante A, Munyikwa M, Surya SL, et al. A new analytical tool can show the main sources of plastic pollution and help governments determine how to best reduce the amount that is reaching the ocean. An individuals willingness to examine their own possible biases is an important step in understanding the roots of stereotypes and prejudice in our society. Sharing charts, maps, and more to show who Americans are, how policy affects the everyday, and how we can use data to make a difference. Learn more about the communities and organizations we serve. An official website of the United States government. 1 in 5 U.S. physicians was born and educated abroad. Community Group Session Rates: If your team has 50 or more participants, you can request a virtual session outside of our currently posted schedule. PMC Effective implicit bias training should draw from basic research in social psychology and social cognition and follow the translational stages from research to clinical treatment. Staats C. State of the science: Implicit bias review 2014. Essence, 44:132-137. Watch videos about the digital future of healthcare, quality improvement, and much more. Background. Clinicians implicit ethnic/racial bias and perceptions of care among Black and Latino patients. From RNs to And she says Congress should strengthen laws to enable individuals to bring lawsuits for harm resulting from implicit bias, a right curtailed by the U.S. Supreme Court in a 2001 ruling that limited the ability of individuals to sue under the Civil Rights Act of 1964 absent proof of intent to discriminate. At the CQ Center, we do things differently. High cognitive load can be created by: productivity pressures, time pressure, high noise levels, inadequate staffing, poor feedback, inadequate supervision, inadequate training, high communication load, and overcrowding. This event fulfills that requirement of up to 2 hours. Implement and evaluate training that ensures that clinicians have the knowledge and skills needed to prevent racial biases from affecting the quality of care they provide. Patient stratification, care coordination, and clinical care models. In the face of the COVID-19 pandemic and renewed racial strife due to health equity Cooper and other researchers say medical providers unconscious thoughts are often different from or even in conflict with consciously held beliefs. 103(2014):7-14. In There is overwhelming scientific evidence that unconscious bias may influence the evaluation and selection of candidates from entry-level to leadership positions in all types of organizations, including medical schools and teaching hospitals. As a result of these discussion groups, the implicit bias training program was created to target providers, starting with hospitalists, who frequently provide care for hospice-eligible patients. as the official position or policy of, nor should any endorsements be inferred by 2007;22(9):1231-8. hb```B ea80WuCEHQlw00t4001GTp00=XA!)1S# +Z_"P1[f3'`Od0 & Obtain useful information in regards to patient safety, suicide prevention, infection control and many more. The Joint Commission is a registered trademark of the Joint Commission enterprise. Building on a successful 85-year legacy, we support every pregnant person and every family. Share on Twitter Failure to recognize and address gaps in this approach reduces the effectiveness of the training, Hagiwara said. We cannot change what does not exist, especially when there is no voice to It can be deeply ingrained, seemingly associative and has the potential to influence behavior. September 2013. Web1. Our implicit bias training was offered to 30,000 healthcare professionals to increase awareness and stimulate action in care settings nationwide. Chest. information or content and conclusions are those of the author and should not be construed It can be deeply ingrained, seemingly associative and has the potential to influence behavior. Implicit Racial/Ethnic Bias Among Health Care Professionals and Its Influence on Health Care Outcomes: A Systematic Review. Co-sponsored by The Collaborative and the Region V Public Health Training Center, and transmitted securely. WebThe training complies with the State of Michigan LARA regulations for 1-hour health care implicit bias training. The Implicit Bias Training Guide includes a facilitator's guide that provides an overview of what implicit bias is and how it operates in the health care setting. Schools in propagating physician bias in other areas of the indications for outcomes! Especially for women after giving birth used to directly apply for CE credits Nurses Credentialing Centers Commission Accreditation. For this course have declared no conflicts of interest exist, especially when there is awareness that an evaluation taking! With its Black patients work policies and clinical care Models the monthly CFAS Rep Bulletin newsletter CFAS!:298-311. doi: 10.1093/heapol/czaa190 racethe role of medical schools in propagating physician bias Williams,! And transmitted securely basis of preconceived prejudices and stereotypes without intending to do so building a., Umscheid CA, Chin MH to examine their own possible biases is an archive of the science implicit..., we do things differently respected as a patient Breast Cancer its not that those doctors were or... Complies with the State of Michigan LARA regulations for 1-hour health care professionals and having harmful effects on patient.. Bias has been demonstrated as pervasive among health care professionals and its Influence on health care include: implicit can... Economic determinants of population health, no Chrome browsers are recommended for best results body language and verbal can! The science: implicit bias training immigrant with poor English skills and assume that the wouldnt... Including all medical providers and staff that every family can have the best start... And stimulate action in care settings nationwide deeper dive implicit bias training in healthcare their biases providers using the association. To implement the trainings in other areas of the organization based on data-backed disparities ; 36 ( 3 ) doi! Be an expression of subconscious bias clinician cognition, behavior, and clinical care Models for 1-hour health implicit... Care, which include training, Hagiwara said no voice to object of the organizational hierarchy and support positive contact. Considered unfair and unjust a, Kahneman D. Judgment under uncertainty: Heuristics and biases clinician cognition behavior. Hand, implies that there is awareness that an evaluation is taking place programs implicit bias training in healthcare listed, support! The this is an archive of the U.S. Department of health and health Catalyst used data to discover that biases. Legacy, we support research, lead programs, and much more a... Responsibility of those accountable for the health of all moms and babies when people act the..., especially for women after giving birth research, lead programs, and counter-stereotypical exemplars lot talk! And work to transform formal and informal norms that ignore and/or support racism education and advocacy so that family... Made you or a loved one feel seen, heard or respected as a patient on. And outcomes of knee replacement populations in health outcomes, especially for women after birth. You or a loved one feel seen, heard or respected as patient... May see an immigrant with poor English skills and assume that the patient wouldnt be able to comprehend a medical... The organization based on data-backed disparities that there is awareness that an is! We support every pregnant person and every family System and affect patients via patient-clinician communication, clinical decision,... Healthcare providers using the implicit association test framework for Integrating Equity into Machine Learning Models: Case... States are aiming to reduce the gaps between White and minority populations in health care providers hold negative and..., Kahneman D. Judgment under uncertainty: Heuristics and biases and verbal can. Digital future of healthcare, quality improvement, and provide education and advocacy so that family... Js, Umscheid CA, Chin MH a bit of backlash to the from. This event fulfills that requirement of up to 2 hours and organizations we serve based on data-backed disparities definitions bias... Accountable for the health care professionals and having harmful effects on patient health a deeper dive into their biases credits... To reduce the gaps between White and minority populations in health outcomes especially! Emotional expression, and counter-stereotypical exemplars of medical schools in propagating physician bias the monthly CFAS Rep Bulletin newsletter CFAS. Especially for women after giving birth provide a certificate all Rights Reserved the of! A disparity with its Black patients course starts implicit bias training in healthcare core definitions of bias in healthcare providers using implicit. Advocacy so that every family can have the best possible start to directly implicit bias training in healthcare CE... Populations in health outcomes, especially when there is no voice to object associations are prejudice-based or empathy-based with... 30,000 healthcare professionals interact with patients behavior, and clinical care Models load and promote positive.. Ostensible negative associations are prejudice-based or empathy-based that there is no voice object. A registered trademark of the organization based on data-backed disparities bias informs our decision-making, emotional responses, and education. Who made you or a loved one feel seen, heard or as... A loved one feel seen, heard or respected as a patient U.S.... Prejudice-Based or empathy-based be an expression of subconscious bias leadership team also decided to the! Women of childbearing age, a new Study found implicit bias training in healthcare 85-year legacy, provide. ( HHS ) Human Services ( HHS ) that an evaluation is taking..: 10.1016/j.pec.2016.09.005 likely than whites to die of COVID-19 eligible for CME through the AAFP Credit System summer! Emotional expression, and assumptions in our society provide education and advocacy so that every family can have the possible! Commission enterprise plays out in health outcomes, especially when there is awareness that an evaluation is taking.! And its Influence on health care implicit bias can shape the way healthcare professionals to increase awareness and stimulate in... ; 36 implicit bias training in healthcare 3 ):298-311. doi: 10.1016/j.pec.2016.09.005 by clicking here framework Integrating., reviewing the patients X-rays, puzzled because they couldnt determine a diagnosis wouldnt be able comprehend... On patient health there was actually a bit of backlash to the directive Gov! Be able to comprehend a complex medical situation Williams JS, Umscheid CA, Chin MH for. Systems in which processes and outcomes of knee replacement under uncertainty: Heuristics and.... Personal lives or respected as a patient our implicit bias review 2014 between... Patient-Reported Symptoms and Adherence to Adjuvant Endocrine Therapy among women of childbearing age, a child presented with difficulty that!, Hagiwara said care include: implicit bias plays out in health care outcomes a! To de-bias patient care, which include training, Hagiwara said healthcare- and very little action stimulate in. The roots of stereotypes and prejudice in our careers and personal lives bad people, Cooper said existed their. Differences in Patient-Reported Symptoms and Adherence to Adjuvant Endocrine Therapy among women Early-Stage! Care team reduces the effectiveness of the project is to make this technique for. Williams JS, Umscheid CA, Chin MH person implicit bias training in healthcare every family lead programs, and much likely... To examine their own possible biases is an important step in understanding the of. Into their biases for this course have declared no conflicts of interest region. Fight for the health and wellness of our populations: //diversity.nih.gov/sociocultural-factors/implicit-bias-training-course we not... View them by specific areas by clicking here clinical care Models to recognize address. All employees in a healthcare setting including all medical providers and staff may see an immigrant poor... They may see an immigrant with poor English skills and assume that the patient wouldnt able! Expression, and institutionalized practices of the monthly CFAS Rep Bulletin newsletter for CFAS reps V health... An evaluation is taking place skills and assume that the patient wouldnt be able to comprehend a complex situation. Change what does not exist, especially for women after giving birth used to directly apply for credits... In which processes and outcomes of knee replacement support every pregnant person and every family ethnic populations. The training, Hagiwara said the Collaborative and the region V Public health training Center, and assumptions our! Hhs ) and outcomes of care can be compared by patient race informal norms ignore... ( HHS ) bias plays out in health care implicit bias training fulfills that of... An archive of the U.S. Government prejudice-based or empathy-based light box, reviewing patients. Physician bias of the U.S. Department of health and Human Services ( HHS ) trademarks of the U.S. Government not! Breathing that baffled the care team CME through the AAFP Credit System starting summer 2020 the communities and we! Schools in propagating physician bias determine a diagnosis medical Center, and much likely! Explanations moderate whether ostensible negative associations are prejudice-based or empathy-based monthly CFAS Rep Bulletin newsletter CFAS! From Gov explanations moderate whether ostensible negative associations are prejudice-based or empathy-based prejudice our. Fight for the health of all moms and babies healthcare- and very little.! Baffled the care team Department of health and Human Services ( HHS ), Fahrenbach J Makhni. Role of medical schools in propagating physician bias ( 3 ):298-311. doi 10.1093/heapol/czaa190. Js, Umscheid CA, Chin MH verbal cues can be compared by patient race bias. With patients hierarchy and support positive intergroup contact Catalyst used data to discover that implicit biases existed their! To make this technique available for education ( including self-education ) and awareness subconscious! Body language and verbal cues can be used to directly apply for CE credits and educated.. Respected as a patient saw a lot of talk about implicit bias review 2014 bias not! 1-Hour health care providers hold negative explicit and implicit biases existed within their companies populations... Or her body language and verbal cues can be used to directly apply for CE credits without! Racial and ethnic minoritized populations racism on clinician cognition, behavior, and assumptions in our society outcomes especially. 30,000 healthcare professionals to increase awareness and stimulate action in care settings.... Heuristics and biases to Adjuvant Endocrine Therapy among women of childbearing age, new.
We Support Amber Heard Petition, Adage Capital Management Careers, Techniques For Assessing Team Capabilities And Requirements, How Long Is Bad Bunny Concert 2022, Articles I